Tow Rig - Need your Input
#11
Forum Regulator
VIP Member
Re: Tow Rig - Need your Input
Another thought... your truck is already a 2500HD isn't it?
Do a search on eBay for a take out (wrecked) Duramax/Allison complete package. You might find a deal.
Do a search on eBay for a take out (wrecked) Duramax/Allison complete package. You might find a deal.
#12
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 615
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Tow Rig - Need your Input
Jassman (and others please)-
Thanks for your response. Funny, as I laid out the points and rated and all of my answers were the same as yours! What I want to know is why you have all 3?
As it relates to your comment on the Dodge transmission - wasn't that a problem before Cummins made the transmissions or is it still a problem?
As mentioned, I was leaning towards the Dodge however, I think for the wrong reasons - b/c it has the best look and is actually the cheapest of the 3. Is this a case of you get what you pay for or would you say this is negligible as they are all high towing capacity diesels and I will only keep the truck for 3 years (so always under warranty)?
My problem with GMC is that I have a 2500HD Gas right now and to go to Diesel will not really let me feel like I am getting a new rig.
My problem with Ford is that their non Lariat packages suck. I don't want leather but I do want the bells and whistles.
More thoughts?
Thanks for your response. Funny, as I laid out the points and rated and all of my answers were the same as yours! What I want to know is why you have all 3?
As it relates to your comment on the Dodge transmission - wasn't that a problem before Cummins made the transmissions or is it still a problem?
As mentioned, I was leaning towards the Dodge however, I think for the wrong reasons - b/c it has the best look and is actually the cheapest of the 3. Is this a case of you get what you pay for or would you say this is negligible as they are all high towing capacity diesels and I will only keep the truck for 3 years (so always under warranty)?
My problem with GMC is that I have a 2500HD Gas right now and to go to Diesel will not really let me feel like I am getting a new rig.
My problem with Ford is that their non Lariat packages suck. I don't want leather but I do want the bells and whistles.
More thoughts?
#13
Platinum Member
Platinum Member
Re: Tow Rig - Need your Input
Originally Posted by On The Heat
Jassman (and others please)-
Thanks for your response. Funny, as I laid out the points and rated and all of my answers were the same as yours! What I want to know is why you have all 3?
As it relates to your comment on the Dodge transmission - wasn't that a problem before Cummins made the transmissions or is it still a problem?
As mentioned, I was leaning towards the Dodge however, I think for the wrong reasons - b/c it has the best look and is actually the cheapest of the 3. Is this a case of you get what you pay for or would you say this is negligible as they are all high towing capacity diesels and I will only keep the truck for 3 years (so always under warranty)?
My problem with GMC is that I have a 2500HD Gas right now and to go to Diesel will not really let me feel like I am getting a new rig.
My problem with Ford is that their non Lariat packages suck. I don't want leather but I do want the bells and whistles.
More thoughts?
Thanks for your response. Funny, as I laid out the points and rated and all of my answers were the same as yours! What I want to know is why you have all 3?
As it relates to your comment on the Dodge transmission - wasn't that a problem before Cummins made the transmissions or is it still a problem?
As mentioned, I was leaning towards the Dodge however, I think for the wrong reasons - b/c it has the best look and is actually the cheapest of the 3. Is this a case of you get what you pay for or would you say this is negligible as they are all high towing capacity diesels and I will only keep the truck for 3 years (so always under warranty)?
My problem with GMC is that I have a 2500HD Gas right now and to go to Diesel will not really let me feel like I am getting a new rig.
My problem with Ford is that their non Lariat packages suck. I don't want leather but I do want the bells and whistles.
More thoughts?
As to the tranny problems with Dodge, I cant keep them together. The Ford tranny has been better to me than the Allison on the GMC. We pull trailers between 10k-19k a day. The Fluids are checked on Saturday's as well as getting them clean in and out, and then a visual inspections.
Of the 3 the Dodge when comparing invoices apples to apples is about 1200k less than the Ford which is 700 less than the GMC. The best resale still is the Ford, the Dodge looses money to quick of the 3 and is always the one that my employees buys, cause when I try to trade in Im always 6-8k behind a new invoice vs 3-4k on the others.
I have always gotten the XLT package with the leather on the 2500/3500 Fords. You can add options to make it close to a Lariat with or without leather. After the storm (lost all 6 trucks) from Ford I ordered 3 Lariats 2-2500's and 1-3500 love them.. worth the extra money. Love the leather on this package vs the XLT. Beter feeling, breaths excellent and easy to clean out and wipe up with some of that Frenzy protectant.
I wish you good luck. Order a Dodge, add the Ford suspension and tranny, with the GMC interior and you got it made. Jeff
#14
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 615
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Tow Rig - Need your Input
Jeff-
Thanks for your time to answer my post - it has helped me quite a bit. However, I think you have left me with a new solution...
How about I come to MS and have you either 1)introduce me to your Ford dealership so I can get that same sweet deal or 2) sell me your '06 Ford since you have an '07 coming .
What '07 Ford did you order...any info you may have? Perhaps I will wait.
Shawn
Thanks for your time to answer my post - it has helped me quite a bit. However, I think you have left me with a new solution...
How about I come to MS and have you either 1)introduce me to your Ford dealership so I can get that same sweet deal or 2) sell me your '06 Ford since you have an '07 coming .
What '07 Ford did you order...any info you may have? Perhaps I will wait.
Shawn
#15
Re: Tow Rig - Need your Input
i'll keep my dodge, it 's a 03 2500short bed. . qc 6 speed 4x4 . the 48 re auto is holding up verry well even with bombing . my 6 speed will pull hell of the hinges with no problems. i have 60k + miles and not and 1 problem . look under the front end . size is massive under the dodge .the ford still uses dana , dodge uses aam axle. it is real big the chey uses aam to but the alum diff housing and axles, are tiney comepaired to the ford and doge . depends on what you are looking if you want it to ride like a caddy and keep it on the road get the chey. if you are going to work it hard and carry heavey loads get the dodge . robbie
#16
Platinum Member
Platinum Member
Re: Tow Rig - Need your Input
Originally Posted by On The Heat
Jeff-
Thanks for your time to answer my post - it has helped me quite a bit. However, I think you have left me with a new solution...
How about I come to MS and have you either 1)introduce me to your Ford dealership so I can get that same sweet deal or 2) sell me your '06 Ford since you have an '07 coming .
What '07 Ford did you order...any info you may have? Perhaps I will wait.
Shawn
Thanks for your time to answer my post - it has helped me quite a bit. However, I think you have left me with a new solution...
How about I come to MS and have you either 1)introduce me to your Ford dealership so I can get that same sweet deal or 2) sell me your '06 Ford since you have an '07 coming .
What '07 Ford did you order...any info you may have? Perhaps I will wait.
Shawn