Is a 5 blade harder on drives than a 4 blade?
#11
Registered
I know what you are saying, but I have yet to shake a carrier loose due to running 3 blades. A lot of other guys I boat with that run O/B's run 4 blades due to less vibration though. I would think the newer XR style cases are even less prone to failure due to excess vibration.
#12
Registered
It depends on if your concern is failures due to reentry or blade induced torsional vibration.
Reentry failure is related to blade area. In general, the more blades you have the greater the total blade surface area. It's possible that a four bladed prop would be worse than a five bladed prop if it's blade area is greater.
With regard to torsional vibration it is a good generalization to assume that vibration levels decrease with the number of blades. Higher frequencies are more easily damped and there is quite a bit of damping in a marine propulsion system. You have to remember that driveline vibration is a function of the whole system. Outdrive type, drive ratio and coupler type all come in to play. In some cases fewer blades are better.
Reentry failure is related to blade area. In general, the more blades you have the greater the total blade surface area. It's possible that a four bladed prop would be worse than a five bladed prop if it's blade area is greater.
With regard to torsional vibration it is a good generalization to assume that vibration levels decrease with the number of blades. Higher frequencies are more easily damped and there is quite a bit of damping in a marine propulsion system. You have to remember that driveline vibration is a function of the whole system. Outdrive type, drive ratio and coupler type all come in to play. In some cases fewer blades are better.
#13
Registered
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Tucson, AZ
Posts: 495
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts