GPS Question
#11
Registered
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: chesapeake bay md
Posts: 959
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Glen if you go to bam marine's site, go-fast.com. click the knowledge base and then speed calculations. Enter your spec. you will see 94mph is Just about right. I am curious what a different GPS indicates
#12
Registered
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally Posted by mmwalters
Glen if you go to bam marine's site, go-fast.com. click the knowledge base and then speed calculations. Enter your spec. you will see 94mph is Just about right. I am curious what a different GPS indicates
#13
Registered
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
My Garmin 172c and Gaffrig analog GPS speedo with recall usually read within 1 MPH of each other. What was your speedo reading?
The only difference I see between mine is that the Gaffrig updates slower, and on a short top end burst may read slower.
Regards,
Steve
The only difference I see between mine is that the Gaffrig updates slower, and on a short top end burst may read slower.
Regards,
Steve
#14
Platinum Member
![](https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/images/icons/platinum_member_star.gif)
Thread Starter
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally Posted by Steve Zuckerman
My Garmin 172c and Gaffrig analog GPS speedo with recall usually read within 1 MPH of each other. What was your speedo reading?
The only difference I see between mine is that the Gaffrig updates slower, and on a short top end burst may read slower.
Regards,
Steve
The only difference I see between mine is that the Gaffrig updates slower, and on a short top end burst may read slower.
Regards,
Steve
We were running way to fast for me to pay a lot of attention to both. I saw my tacks @ 5400+ and my small GPS towards the end of our few mile run.
On Fri I will hook up a new 100mph Livorsi recall GPS speedo and give it another shot along with the other units!
#16
Platinum Member
![](https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/images/icons/platinum_member_star.gif)
Thread Starter
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally Posted by mmwalters
Glen Well ? did you install the GPS speedo? What is your real speed?
#17
Registered
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
WW:
One other thing you might check. My 172c was shipped from the factory with the speed reading preset in knots per hour.
It was doing the same thing as yours, and really f'ing me up until I noticed it said kt beside the readout.
When I reset it to mph, I noticed there was 3rd option of statute miles which would also result in goofy readings. You've probably already reset yours to MPH, but FYI anyway.
Let us know how it turns out. By the way, I mounted my antenna under the deck, and it works perfectly.
Regards,
Steve
One other thing you might check. My 172c was shipped from the factory with the speed reading preset in knots per hour.
It was doing the same thing as yours, and really f'ing me up until I noticed it said kt beside the readout.
When I reset it to mph, I noticed there was 3rd option of statute miles which would also result in goofy readings. You've probably already reset yours to MPH, but FYI anyway.
Let us know how it turns out. By the way, I mounted my antenna under the deck, and it works perfectly.
Regards,
Steve
#18
Registered
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Long island
Posts: 422
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I use the GPS to check top speed but monitor my Gaffrig(non-gps) for trimming, cruise, etc.. Its always 1-2mph faster then the gps but its much quicker to react to small changes in trim or throttle.
#19
![Default](/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Without knowing too much about the boat, here is what the performance of a boat such as this should be:
Manufacturer: Cigarette
Model: Top Gun
Length: 38 ft
Beam: 8 ft 6 in
Weight: 9800 lb
Deadrise Angle: 24 deg
Hull Depth: 6 ft
Number of Running Strakes: 2
Number of Transverse Ventilated Steps: 0
Hull does not have a keelpad
Boat has an open cockpit
Engine information:
Boat has 2 x 572 c.i. Supercharged/Intercooled engines installed
Engine Redline: 5800 RPM
Peak BHP is 800 BHP occuring at 5600 RPM
Peak Torque is 850 lb-ft occuring at 4400 RPM
Drive information:
Boat has 2 x Bravo One, X, XZ, XR Drives Installed, with 1.35:1 gears
Propeller information:
Propeller: 4 bladed Bravo 1
Prop Diameter: 15.25 in
Prop Pitch: 29 in
Prop is set 30 inches behind, and 6 inches below the running surface
Environmental Conditions:
Boat is to be simulated operating in Salt Water, at 0 ft above msl, with an ambient air temperature of 80 degrees F
Program Completed
Computational Results
Your boat's computed performance is as follows:
SPEED(mph) ENGINE RPM REQ'D BHP AVAILABLE BHP PROP SLIP WETTED LENGTH(ft)
25.00 1989 219 432 39.17 21.81
26.00 2037 228 447 38.20 21.34
27.00 2085 237 462 37.29 20.91
28.00 2133 246 478 36.42 20.50
29.00 2182 256 494 35.60 20.13
30.00 2227 264 510 34.75 19.56
31.00 2277 274 527 34.01 19.23
32.00 2323 282 542 33.23 18.71
33.00 2372 292 560 32.57 18.43
34.00 2418 301 576 31.85 17.95
35.00 2468 312 594 31.25 17.70
36.00 2515 322 611 30.60 17.27
37.00 2562 331 627 29.97 16.85
38.00 2612 344 646 29.45 16.65
39.00 2659 354 663 28.87 16.26
40.00 2706 365 681 28.32 15.89
41.00 2753 376 698 27.79 15.54
42.00 2804 390 717 27.36 15.38
43.00 2852 401 735 26.87 15.06
44.00 2899 413 753 26.39 14.74
45.00 2947 426 772 25.94 14.44
46.00 2999 441 791 25.58 14.32
47.00 3047 454 810 25.16 14.04
48.00 3095 468 828 24.75 13.76
49.00 3143 481 847 24.36 13.50
50.00 3191 495 865 23.98 13.24
51.00 3239 510 884 23.61 13.00
52.00 3288 524 903 23.26 12.76
53.00 3340 543 923 23.00 12.69
54.00 3388 558 942 22.67 12.47
55.00 3437 574 961 22.35 12.25
56.00 3486 590 979 22.04 12.04
57.00 3535 606 998 21.74 11.84
58.00 3583 623 1017 21.46 11.64
59.00 3632 640 1036 21.18 11.45
60.00 3681 658 1054 20.91 11.27
61.00 3731 675 1073 20.65 11.09
62.00 3784 698 1093 20.47 11.06
63.00 3833 716 1111 20.22 10.89
64.00 3882 735 1129 19.99 10.72
65.00 3932 754 1147 19.76 10.56
66.00 3981 774 1165 19.53 10.40
67.00 4031 794 1183 19.32 10.25
68.00 4080 814 1200 19.11 10.10
69.00 4130 835 1217 18.91 9.965
70.00 4180 856 1234 18.71 9.825
71.00 4229 877 1251 18.52 9.689
72.00 4279 899 1268 18.33 9.556
73.00 4329 921 1284 18.15 9.427
74.00 4379 944 1300 17.98 9.300
75.00 4429 967 1315 17.81 9.178
76.00 4479 990 1330 17.64 9.058
77.00 4529 1014 1345 17.48 8.941
78.00 4579 1038 1359 17.33 8.827
79.00 4630 1063 1373 17.17 8.715
80.00 4684 1094 1388 17.08 8.720
81.00 4734 1119 1401 16.93 8.612
82.00 4784 1145 1413 16.79 8.507
83.00 4835 1172 1425 16.66 8.404
84.00 4885 1199 1436 16.52 8.304
85.00 4936 1226 1447 16.39 8.206
86.00 4986 1254 1457 16.27 8.110
87.00 5037 1283 1467 16.14 8.016
88.00 5087 1311 1476 16.02 7.924
89.00 5138 1341 1484 15.91 7.834
90.00 5189 1370 1492 15.79 7.746
91.00 5240 1401 1498 15.68 7.660
92.00 5290 1431 1504 15.57 7.576
93.00 5341 1463 1510 15.47 7.493
94.00 5392 1495 1514 15.37 7.412
94.71 5429 1518 1518 15.27 7.333
Looks like the 94-95 GPS unit might be the winner. If your temperature was cooler than the 80F I assumed, or if your motors are actually 800 "+", then you should see a little more. Note that my predictions always adjust the motors' output based on ambient temp and altitude. The wind drag also changes some with these parameters. This program actually calculates propeller slip based on individual blade loading. The amount of cavitation and ventilation vary with prop height. The code computes exactly how high the water will rise from the transom to where it meets the drive unit and propeller based on trim angle, drive height, setback, and speed. So, not only can I predict propeller performance using the method, but I can see how much drive drag you will get with changes in installed height for each different type of drive unit.
It sounds complicated, and it is, but it works.
Go to http://www.speedboatperformance.com, and run the calculator there. It does account for propeller blade loading, drive height and setback, as well as hull configuration. Give it a try while it is free!
Manufacturer: Cigarette
Model: Top Gun
Length: 38 ft
Beam: 8 ft 6 in
Weight: 9800 lb
Deadrise Angle: 24 deg
Hull Depth: 6 ft
Number of Running Strakes: 2
Number of Transverse Ventilated Steps: 0
Hull does not have a keelpad
Boat has an open cockpit
Engine information:
Boat has 2 x 572 c.i. Supercharged/Intercooled engines installed
Engine Redline: 5800 RPM
Peak BHP is 800 BHP occuring at 5600 RPM
Peak Torque is 850 lb-ft occuring at 4400 RPM
Drive information:
Boat has 2 x Bravo One, X, XZ, XR Drives Installed, with 1.35:1 gears
Propeller information:
Propeller: 4 bladed Bravo 1
Prop Diameter: 15.25 in
Prop Pitch: 29 in
Prop is set 30 inches behind, and 6 inches below the running surface
Environmental Conditions:
Boat is to be simulated operating in Salt Water, at 0 ft above msl, with an ambient air temperature of 80 degrees F
Program Completed
Computational Results
Your boat's computed performance is as follows:
SPEED(mph) ENGINE RPM REQ'D BHP AVAILABLE BHP PROP SLIP WETTED LENGTH(ft)
25.00 1989 219 432 39.17 21.81
26.00 2037 228 447 38.20 21.34
27.00 2085 237 462 37.29 20.91
28.00 2133 246 478 36.42 20.50
29.00 2182 256 494 35.60 20.13
30.00 2227 264 510 34.75 19.56
31.00 2277 274 527 34.01 19.23
32.00 2323 282 542 33.23 18.71
33.00 2372 292 560 32.57 18.43
34.00 2418 301 576 31.85 17.95
35.00 2468 312 594 31.25 17.70
36.00 2515 322 611 30.60 17.27
37.00 2562 331 627 29.97 16.85
38.00 2612 344 646 29.45 16.65
39.00 2659 354 663 28.87 16.26
40.00 2706 365 681 28.32 15.89
41.00 2753 376 698 27.79 15.54
42.00 2804 390 717 27.36 15.38
43.00 2852 401 735 26.87 15.06
44.00 2899 413 753 26.39 14.74
45.00 2947 426 772 25.94 14.44
46.00 2999 441 791 25.58 14.32
47.00 3047 454 810 25.16 14.04
48.00 3095 468 828 24.75 13.76
49.00 3143 481 847 24.36 13.50
50.00 3191 495 865 23.98 13.24
51.00 3239 510 884 23.61 13.00
52.00 3288 524 903 23.26 12.76
53.00 3340 543 923 23.00 12.69
54.00 3388 558 942 22.67 12.47
55.00 3437 574 961 22.35 12.25
56.00 3486 590 979 22.04 12.04
57.00 3535 606 998 21.74 11.84
58.00 3583 623 1017 21.46 11.64
59.00 3632 640 1036 21.18 11.45
60.00 3681 658 1054 20.91 11.27
61.00 3731 675 1073 20.65 11.09
62.00 3784 698 1093 20.47 11.06
63.00 3833 716 1111 20.22 10.89
64.00 3882 735 1129 19.99 10.72
65.00 3932 754 1147 19.76 10.56
66.00 3981 774 1165 19.53 10.40
67.00 4031 794 1183 19.32 10.25
68.00 4080 814 1200 19.11 10.10
69.00 4130 835 1217 18.91 9.965
70.00 4180 856 1234 18.71 9.825
71.00 4229 877 1251 18.52 9.689
72.00 4279 899 1268 18.33 9.556
73.00 4329 921 1284 18.15 9.427
74.00 4379 944 1300 17.98 9.300
75.00 4429 967 1315 17.81 9.178
76.00 4479 990 1330 17.64 9.058
77.00 4529 1014 1345 17.48 8.941
78.00 4579 1038 1359 17.33 8.827
79.00 4630 1063 1373 17.17 8.715
80.00 4684 1094 1388 17.08 8.720
81.00 4734 1119 1401 16.93 8.612
82.00 4784 1145 1413 16.79 8.507
83.00 4835 1172 1425 16.66 8.404
84.00 4885 1199 1436 16.52 8.304
85.00 4936 1226 1447 16.39 8.206
86.00 4986 1254 1457 16.27 8.110
87.00 5037 1283 1467 16.14 8.016
88.00 5087 1311 1476 16.02 7.924
89.00 5138 1341 1484 15.91 7.834
90.00 5189 1370 1492 15.79 7.746
91.00 5240 1401 1498 15.68 7.660
92.00 5290 1431 1504 15.57 7.576
93.00 5341 1463 1510 15.47 7.493
94.00 5392 1495 1514 15.37 7.412
94.71 5429 1518 1518 15.27 7.333
Looks like the 94-95 GPS unit might be the winner. If your temperature was cooler than the 80F I assumed, or if your motors are actually 800 "+", then you should see a little more. Note that my predictions always adjust the motors' output based on ambient temp and altitude. The wind drag also changes some with these parameters. This program actually calculates propeller slip based on individual blade loading. The amount of cavitation and ventilation vary with prop height. The code computes exactly how high the water will rise from the transom to where it meets the drive unit and propeller based on trim angle, drive height, setback, and speed. So, not only can I predict propeller performance using the method, but I can see how much drive drag you will get with changes in installed height for each different type of drive unit.
It sounds complicated, and it is, but it works.
Go to http://www.speedboatperformance.com, and run the calculator there. It does account for propeller blade loading, drive height and setback, as well as hull configuration. Give it a try while it is free!
Last edited by tcelano; 09-22-2005 at 11:14 PM.