im MartinB

I borrowed a friends 30 P5X last season and ran it on my 280 Velocity. It loved it. He doesn't want to sell it and I'm wondering if there is anything comparable that works similar. I tried labbed and standard Bravo ones and the boat lost about 3-4mph and also starts chime walking a lot when you get it up on the pad. I see some Signature 5 blades for sale but I haven't been able to try one. It seems odd to me that this boat likes the p5X so much, when I put them on another boat with twins I lost about 5mph compared to the 30 Labbed Bravo ones. I plan to sell the boat this spring and want to get something on there that doesn't chime walk and still performs decent.

Brad Christy

Martin,

I would think Merc's Maximus would be a better equivalent, unless they are not shaft compatible (?). additionally, I have been told by numerous people, including Hydromotive, that their props tend to be higher pitch than equivalent Bravo props, not to mention losing the effect of the additional blade (more slip, I'd think).

Thanks. Brad.

JaniH

P5x is great prop for sure! I have always wanted to test the cutting edge bravo style 5 blade, you might want check that one.

JaniH

https://cuttingedgepropellers.com/our-props/

87MirageIntruder

I've got Cutting Edge 28P and 30p 5 blade props and I like them on my Nordic Heat.

im MartinB

Do you have any direct comparisons with this prop against something more common by chance? Thus far I've really liked every 5 blade I've spun but they've all lowered my slip down to 12-15% and I am going for closer to 18-20%. Running Bravo ones labbed and slip is 23-25% and it's like that through out all the speeds 3500-6000.

87MirageIntruder

On my Nordic Heat, the 5 blade cutting edge props run about 4% less slip than a bravo one 4 blade. I had them make the 5 blades to 15" so that could explain why they have a bit more slip than a typical 5 blade. I think many 5 blades are at least 15.25 and larger.

larose481

Id say the Maximus would be your closest. I have run the P5X, Maximus, and Cutting Edge and settled on the maximus. They are all bow lift props and the P5X is in the middle with the Maximus having a bit more and the Cutting Edge having slightly less. Prop slip on my single engine Dominator is simply amazing with it. Augie at Cutting Edge worked with me to try and duplicate it and got very close but its not the same but does work good and that is my spare. Check with BBlades and see if they still have Maximus in their test program.